Quad9 withdraws free DNS resolver from France after court-ordered piracy blockingImage: blog.cloudflare.com
Cooling

Quad9 withdraws free DNS resolver from France after court-ordered piracy blocking

Heat 58 · #20 in Tech · Cooling4 reports · 3 sources · First reported Nov 17 · Updated Nov 20

The story

Quad9 will withdraw its free public DNS resolver from France, ending service on November 24, after a French court ruling imposed daily penalties for failing to block domains linked to alleged copyright infringement, including beIN Sports and WTA streams. The announcement followed months of litigation over the blocking orders. Quad9 says the penalty was cut from the EUR 580,000 per day demanded to EUR 1,000 per day, about EUR 24,000 in total, but that it cannot comply long-term while protecting user privacy. Cisco's OpenDNS left France in 2024 under a similar order, and a Belgian court order would impose penalties on Cloudflare, Google and Cisco from early January 2027 if they do not block the domains.
Latest development
cooling per rule: score 78.0->58.0 (formula 78.0 - 20)

How it unfolded

  1. cooling per rule: score 78.0->58.0 (formula 78.0 - 20)
  2. cooling revival per rounds 35/195 precedent: score 58.0->78.0 (rank 60, discussion 100, cross 70), cooling cleared
  3. Nov 19, 17:08
    own HN post 50545958 back in HN top 30 at #30, 661 pts/268 cmt
  4. no Lobsters/YouTube lifeline in discovery 202
  5. post title now 'DNS resolvers are the wrong place to fight piracy', same hn_id
  6. the other Quad9 post 50545958 left the top 30
  7. Techmeme Quad9 item re-appears, already merged
  8. Techmeme Cloudflare item re-appears, already merged
  9. Techmeme item re-appears, already merged
  10. same-event merge: new HN #4 post 50545958 (Quad9's own blog, 5 pts) 'Quad9 Is Leaving France', not a new row
  11. same post, same pts/cmt as round 163
  12. Techmeme item (Cloudflare blog) re-appears, already merged
  13. same post, same pts/cmt as round 162
  14. Belgian court order would impose penalties on Cloudflare, Google and Cisco from early Jan 2027 if they do not block
  15. Cisco's OpenDNS left France in 2024 under a similar order
  16. Oct 27
    EFF 2026-10-27 + TorrentFreak coverage
  17. Oct 22
    Quad9 official blog 2026-10-22: service ends 2026-11-24, penalty cut from EUR 580,000/day demanded to EUR 1,000/day (about EUR 24,000 total), cannot comply long-term while protecting privacy
  18. Nov 17
    Cloudflare blog 2026-11-17: Quad9 announced last month it will withdraw its free public DNS resolver from France after months of litigation and a French court ruling imposing daily penalties for failing to block domains linked to alleged copyright infringement (beIN Sports / WTA streams)

The angle

Why Quad9 is leaving France, what the court ordered, and why Cloudflare calls it a canary in the coal mine for DNS-level blockingSuggested format: Short video · for Privacy and internet-freedom audience, developers

Coverage (4)

CloudflareCloudflare
Quad9Quad9
Hacker NewsHacker News
Hacker NewsHacker News

Heat

Now 58 · Peak 58 · 64 recorded checks since Nov 20
Full ranking →