Cooling

We need smart people who give a s***

Heat 50 · #45 in Tech · Cooling2 reports · 2 sources · First reported Nov 17 · Updated Nov 20

The story

Critical systems are held together by a shrinking group of experts who know them intimately and care enough to keep them working, a former Stripe engineer argues in a blog post. The post uses the ACH banking network as its example of a fragile system that runs because knowledgeable people force it to work. It points to the past week's failures — Microsoft 365, air traffic control, United Airlines, the NSA network, major banks and Apple systems — as a symptom. Those experts, the post says, are being laid off and replaced with generative AI, which, in the author's words, 'isn't smart, and it doesn't give a s***.'
Latest developmentNov 21, 03:06
Lobsters #13 same post, keepalive note only (191 pts/70 cmt, was #13, 191 pts/69 cmt

How it unfolded

  1. Nov 21, 03:06
    Lobsters #13 same post, keepalive note only (191 pts/70 cmt, was #13, 191 pts/69 cmt
  2. Nov 21, 02:36
    Lobsters #13 same post, keepalive note only (191 pts/69 cmt, was #12, 190 pts/68 cmt
  3. Nov 21, 02:06
    Lobsters #12 same post, keepalive note only (190 pts/68 cmt, was #12, 189 pts/68 cmt
  4. Nov 21, 01:37
    Lobsters #12 same post, keepalive note only (189 pts/68 cmt, was #12, 187 pts/68 cmt
  5. Nov 21, 01:08
    Lobsters #12 same post, keepalive note only (187 pts/68 cmt, was #12, 187 pts/65 cmt
  6. Nov 21, 00:44
    Lobsters #12 same post, keepalive note only (187 pts/65 cmt, was #12, 187 pts/64 cmt
  7. Nov 21, 00:25
    Lobsters #12 same post, keepalive note only (187 pts/64 cmt, was #11, 186 pts/61 cmt
  8. Nov 20, 23:58
    Lobsters #11 same post, keepalive note only (186 pts/61 cmt, was #10, 183 pts/61 cmt
  9. Nov 20, 23:16
    Lobsters #10 same post, keepalive note only (183 pts/61 cmt, was #9, 179 pts/61 cmt
  10. Nov 20, 22:47
    Lobsters #9 same post, keepalive note only (183 pts/61 cmt, was #8, 179 pts/61 cmt
  11. Nov 20, 22:16
    Lobsters #8 same post, keepalive note only (179 pts/61 cmt, was #7, 179 pts/59 cmt
  12. row unchanged, still cooling 50.0
  13. Nov 20, 05:36
    Lobsters #3 same post, keepalive note only
  14. Nov 20, 00:36
    Lobsters #1 same post, keepalive note only
  15. Nov 20, 00:08
    Lobsters #2 same post, keepalive note only
  16. Nov 19, 23:38
    Lobsters #4 same post (5 comments), keepalive note only
  17. Nov 19, 23:06
    Lobsters #7 same post (3 comments), keepalive note only
  18. row unchanged, still cooling
  19. Nov 19, 22:35
    Lobsters #12 same post (1 comment), keepalive note only
  20. dammnews/everythingblog/vuink echoes are aggregator mirrors, not a second platform.
  21. single-platform HN item, admitted at 68.0 per the single-platform precedent (rounds 130/154)
  22. cites the past week's failures (Microsoft 365, air traffic control, United Airlines, NSA network, major banks, Apple systems) as the symptom: those experts are being laid off and replaced with generative AI, which 'isn't smart, and it doesn't give a s***'
  23. author (ex-Stripe) argues the world is held together by smart people who give a s***: people with intimate knowledge of fragile systems (ACH banking example) plus the drive to force them to work

The angle

Why the week's outages share one cause, and why AI cannot replace the people who hold the systems togetherSuggested format: Short video · for Tech workers, AI skeptics, people worried about AI replacing jobs

Heat

Now 50 · Peak 50 · 64 recorded checks since Nov 20
Full ranking →