Why is Gemini 4 Carbon taking so long? It finds the bug fast but waits 25 minutes to fix itImage: kernel.dev
Cooling

Why is Gemini 4 Carbon taking so long? It finds the bug fast but waits 25 minutes to fix it

Heat 46 · #34 in AI · Cooling3 reports · 3 sources · First reported Nov 18 · Updated Nov 20

The story

Google's Gemini 4 Carbon finds bugs quickly but then waits a long time before fixing them, according to a sample trial published by kernel.dev. In the trial, GPT-6 Astra at maximum effort and Carbon at high effort both identified the cause early — Astra in under a minute, Carbon in about six — but Carbon wrote no code for another 25 minutes. When the testers injected a check-in every five turns asking whether it had enough to act, Carbon finished in 28 minutes instead of 37, with the idle wait shrinking to about 10 minutes, suggesting the delay is behavioral rather than a knowledge gap. Separately, developer Theo Browne measured Carbon at roughly five times slower than rivals on coding work across nine review rounds, and Google's Varun Mohan has said on X that the company is looking into the speed.
Latest development
same post, same pts/cmt as round 163

How it unfolded

  1. same post, same pts/cmt as round 163
  2. same post, same pts/cmt as round 162
  3. round 152 settled this post at 56.0 below the line, now risen to HN #8
  4. Nov 13
    search corroboration, same angle: Theo Browne video 2026-11-13, Carbon ~5x slower than rivals at coding, 11+ sec before first reply, 16 min 44 sec avg over 9 review rounds vs Claude Opus 5.5 3 min 31 sec, Google's Varun Mohan replied on X that Google is looking into speed (dailyagentic 2026-11-14), cross 30 -> 50
  5. with a check-in injected every 5 turns ('do you already have enough to make the fix?') Carbon finished in 28 min instead of 37, wait shrank 25 -> ~10 min, so the slowness is behaviour, not knowledge
  6. kernel.dev blog sample trial: GPT-6 Astra at max effort vs Gemini 4 Carbon at high, both found the cause early (Astra <1 min, Carbon ~6 min) but Carbon wrote no code for another 25 min

The angle

Carbon is not slow because it does not know - it is slow because it will not act; the check-in trick that cut a 37-minute job to 28, and why Google's top model feels slower than its rivalsSuggested format: Short video · for AI followers, developers

Heat

Now 46 · Peak 46 · 64 recorded checks since Nov 20
Full ranking →