#1170.0ScienceT1 — official sourceRising

'Birdbrain' is a misnomer: crows decide twice as fast as humans (Science study)

Spotted 2026-11-16 05:07 (UTC+8) · original event 2026-10-22 · sources: Hacker News, NYT, NY Post, phys.org, ScienceAlert · spreading on 3 platforms

Heat score

Rank score: 6040% — where it sits on the charts
Discussion score: 8040% — how much people are talking about it
Cross-platform score: 7020% — how many platforms it spread to
Composite heat score:70.0rank × 0.4 + discussion × 0.4 + cross-platform × 0.2

Why it matters

For generations 'birdbrain' meant stupid -- now the science says the insult is backwards: a crow's brain decides faster than ours on the standard test of decision-making.

The angle

Turns out 'birdbrain' is a compliment -- crows out-decide us in a fifth of a secondSuggested format: Short video · for General public, science-curious viewers

Evidence chain

• HN #3, 81 pts/50 cmt (2026-11-16)• NYT 2026-11-15: two carrion crows trained on the classic random-dot-motion task averaged ~235 ms to judge which way dots were drifting and peck an answer -- roughly twice as fast as humans and monkeys on matched versions of the task, with no loss of accuracy• researchers Philipp Schmidbauer and Andreas Nieder (University of Tubingen) recorded 248 neurons in the nidopallium caudolaterale and could predict the crow's decision ~70 ms after the dots appeared, ~170 ms before the peck• study published in Science 2026-10-22 (DOI 10.1126/science.aed6459)• corroborated by NY Post 2026-10-31, phys.org 2026-10-25 (Tubingen), ScienceAlert 2026-10-30, NPR and Live Science• caveats: only two crows, one visual task, and speed on this task is not proof of general intelligence -- the finding is that a bird brain without a mammalian neocortex accumulates evidence and commits using dynamics strikingly similar to primates• 2026-11-16 06:07 update: HN #3, 100 pts/75 cmt• score 76.0->80.0 (rank 95, discussion 70, cross 70)• 2026-11-16 07:07 update: HN #5, 125 pts/92 cmt• score 80.0->78.0 (rank 90, discussion 70, cross 70)• 2026-11-16 08:07 update: HN #7, 148 pts/108 cmt• score 78.0->76.0 (rank 90->85, discussion 70, cross 70)• 2026-11-16 09:07 update: HN #8, 162 pts/121 cmt• score unchanged 76.0 (rank 85, discussion 70, cross 70)• 2026-11-16 10:07 update: HN #9, 172 pts/125 cmt• score unchanged 76.0 (rank 85, discussion 70, cross 70)• 2026-11-16 11:07 update: HN #9, 182 pts/136 cmt• score unchanged 76.0 (rank 85, discussion 70, cross 70)• 2026-11-16 12:07 update: HN #11, 189 pts/140 cmt• score 76.0->72.0 (rank 85->75, discussion 70, cross 70)• 2026-11-16 13:07 update: HN #14, 196 pts/144 cmt• score unchanged 72.0 (rank 75, discussion 70, cross 70)• 2026-11-16 14:07 update: HN #14, 207 pts/145 cmt• score 72.0->76.0 (rank 75, discussion 70->80, cross 70)• 2026-11-16 15:07 update: HN #14, 220 pts/149 cmt• score unchanged 76.0 (rank 75, discussion 80, cross 70)• 2026-11-16 16:07 update: HN #15, 226 pts/151 cmt• score unchanged 76.0 (rank 75, discussion 80, cross 70)• 2026-11-16 17:07 update: HN #16, 231 pts/157 cmt• score unchanged 76.0 (rank 75, discussion 80, cross 70)• 2026-11-16 18:07 update: HN #14, 238 pts/165 cmt• score unchanged 76.0 (rank 75, discussion 80, cross 70)• 2026-11-16 19:07 update: HN #17, 246 pts/166 cmt• score unchanged 76.0 (rank 75, discussion 80, cross 70)• 2026-11-16 20:07 update: HN #22, 252 pts/171 cmt• score 76.0->70.0 (rank 75->60, discussion 80, cross 70)• 2026-11-16 21:07 update: HN #21, 256 pts/176 cmt• score unchanged 70.0 (rank 60, discussion 80, cross 70)• 2026-11-16 22:07 update: HN #22, 265 pts/180 cmt• score unchanged 70.0 (rank 60, discussion 80, cross 70)• 2026-11-16 23:07 update: HN #27, 273 pts/182 cmt• score unchanged 70.0 (rank 60, discussion 80, cross 70)