#1964.0GamingT2 — media / chartCooling

The Secret of Monkey Island: all 13 versions side by side

Spotted 2026-11-14 18:07 (UTC+8) · original event 2026-11-12 · sources: Hacker News, Lobsters, lockergnome.com, monkeyisland.pages.dev · spreading on 4 platforms

Heat score

Rank score: 7540% — where it sits on the charts
Discussion score: 9040% — how much people are talking about it
Cross-platform score: 9020% — how many platforms it spread to
Composite heat score:64.0rank × 0.4 + discussion × 0.4 + cross-platform × 0.2 — includes a -20-point cooling decay (peak passed, attention fading).

Why it matters

Retro games look different on every machine they shipped on, and nostalgia is machine-specific - a side-by-side viewer settles decades of 'which version looked best' arguments with evidence instead of memory.

The angle

The same 12 scenes of Monkey Island across all 13 releases, side by side - and why the FM Towns version looks so goodSuggested format: Short video · for Retro gamers, 90s PC gamers, game preservation fans

Evidence chain

• HN #3, 105 pts/18 cmt (2026-11-14)• fan-made web viewer monkeyisland.pages.dev by The Paninos off-line: all 13 releases of The Secret of Monkey Island side by side, same 12 scenes in every version, CRT shader tuned to each machine's monitor (PC 16-color/EGA/CGA, Atari ST mono and color, Mac, Amiga, Sega CD, FM Towns, Hercules)• every screen captured in ScummVM (Atari ST mono in Hatari) at 1600x1200• lockergnome.com 2026-11-13 writeup• also on Lobsters 2026-11-12• fan-made, not affiliated with Lucasfilm Games, LucasArts or Disney• 2026-11-14 19:07 update: HN #3, 149 pts/38 cmt• rank 95, discussion 80 -> 70• 2026-11-14 20:07 update: HN #3, 189 pts/58 cmt• 2026-11-14 21:07 update: HN #3, 228 pts/73 cmt• discussion 70 -> 80• 2026-11-14 22:08 update: HN #4, 265 pts/83 cmt• rank 95 -> 90• 2026-11-14 23:07 update: HN #10, 295 pts/86 cmt• rank 90 -> 85• 2026-11-15 00:07 update: HN #12, 319 pts/97 cmt• 2026-11-15 01:07 update: HN #14, 341 pts/112 cmt• score unchanged 84.0• 2026-11-15 02:08 update: HN #14, 366 pts/123 cmt• score unchanged 84.0 (rank 75, discussion 90, cross 90)• 2026-11-15 03:07 update: HN #15, 387 pts/133 cmt• rank 85 -> 75, discussion 80 -> 90• composite unchanged 84.0• 2026-11-15 04:07 update: HN #16, 402 pts/137 cmt• score unchanged 84.0 (rank 75, discussion 90, cross 90)• 2026-11-15 05:07 update: HN #15, 423 pts/139 cmt• score unchanged 84.0 (rank 75, discussion 90, cross 90)• 2026-11-15 06:07 update: HN #17, 440 pts/141 cmt• score unchanged 84.0 (rank 75, discussion 90, cross 90)• 2026-11-15 07:07 update: dropped out of HN top 30• cooling -20 (84.0 -> 64.0)