We're Asking an Appeals Court to Require a Warrant for ALPR Searches
Spotted 2026-11-15 13:07 (UTC+8) · original event 2026-11-09 · sources: Hacker News, EFF, ACLU · spreading on 3 platformsHeat score
Rank score: 6040% — where it sits on the charts
Discussion score: 8040% — how much people are talking about it
Cross-platform score: 7020% — how many platforms it spread to
Composite heat score:50.0rank × 0.4 + discussion × 0.4 + cross-platform × 0.2 — includes a -20-point cooling decay (peak passed, attention fading).
Why it matters
Police can reconstruct anyone's movements from a networked archive of plate sightings without a warrant -- the question is whether searching that archive counts as a search at all.The angle
Your car's movements are already in a searchable database -- EFF wants a warrant before police can lookSuggested format: Short video · for Privacy-conscious general audience, drivers, US tech audienceEvidence chain
• HN #7, 133 pts/25 cmt (2026-11-15)• EFF deeplinks 2026-11-09 (Andrew Crocker): EFF + ACLU filed an amicus brief in the Sixth Circuit in US v. Sturdivant, asking the court to hold warrantless searches of stored ALPR data violate the Fourth Amendment• Cleveland-area police ran open-ended Flock/ELSAG database searches without knowing the suspect's plate in advance, then used hits to arrest• district court held no reasonable expectation of privacy in a publicly visible plate• ACLU of Ohio statement 2026-11-10• Security Ledger 2026-11-11 coverage• Oklahoma district court (US v. Kyle, 2026-10-01) held an ALPR query was a Fourth Amendment search• not a ruling -- Sixth Circuit has not decided• 2026-11-15 14:07 update: HN #8, 161 pts/38 cmt• score unchanged 76.0 (rank 85, discussion 70, cross 70)• 2026-11-15 15:07 update: HN #11, 189 pts/52 cmt• score 76.0->72.0 (rank 85->75, discussion 70, cross 70)• 2026-11-15 16:07 update: HN #14, 205 pts/55 cmt• score 72.0->76.0 (rank 75, discussion 70->80, cross 70)• 2026-11-15 17:07 update: HN #16, 221 pts/57 cmt• score unchanged 76.0 (rank 75, discussion 80, cross 70)• 2026-11-15 18:07 update: HN #21, 228 pts/59 cmt• score 76.0->70.0 (rank 75->60, discussion 80, cross 70)• 2026-11-15 19:07 update: HN #22, 237 pts/67 cmt• score unchanged 70.0 (rank 60, discussion 80, cross 70)• 2026-11-15 20:07 update: HN #22, 249 pts/68 cmt• score unchanged 70.0 (rank 60, discussion 80, cross 70)• 2026-11-15 21:07 update: HN #22, 263 pts/72 cmt• score unchanged 70.0 (rank 60, discussion 80, cross 70)• 2026-11-15 22:07 update: HN #26, 276 pts/74 cmt• score unchanged 70.0 (rank 60, discussion 80, cross 70)• 2026-11-15 23:07 update: dropped out of HN top 30• cooling -20 (70.0 -> 50.0)